November 23, 2024

2 thoughts on “The Flower Kings – ‘Desolation Rose’ Album Review

  1. Nice review – appreciative, good use of comparisons which convey the feel of the music. It seems, though, that you make an error of attribution which occurs often – many of the vocals you attribute to Roine are actually Hasse Fröberg, who sings all of the higher, smoother lines, and whose timbre blends beautifully with Roine’s. A comparison would be Roine = Lennon, Hasse = McCartney……or, Roine = Gabriel, Hasse = Collins, tho the latter two are similar enough in phrasing, not timbre that they overlap. At no time does Roine sound like Jon Anderson, an error made by another reviewer with similar observations as yours – not possible. The high, almost-cracking voice in Silent Masses is in a crescendo when Hasse takes the lead from Roine. Roine rarely goes into that range. Otherwise, beautiful work!

    1. Hi Daniel,

      Thank you so much for your informative comment – I had totally missed the way the vocals are split and I appreciate your taking the time and trouble to share your thoughts on both the review and to set the record straight! Hopefully we’ll see you here again. Phil

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Verified by MonsterInsights